Building for the future: Between EU taxonomy and structural design
Sustainability is no longer a niche topic in the construction industry - it is an ecological necessity. As the construction sector is responsible for a massive proportion of global CO2 emissions, budding civil engineers like Lea Hofmann have a special responsibility. In her award-winning bachelor's thesis, she investigated how materials can be selected in the construction industry in line with political requirements.
HKA: Ms. Hübner, what did you focus on in your bachelor's thesis?
Lena Hübner (LH): I developed an electric motor with a so-called follower pole rotor. The motor was a permanent-magnet synchronous machine. Put simply, such a motor contains a large number of magnets that are attached to the rotor in alternating polarity. The problem is that the permanent magnets are pretty much the most expensive components on such a motor. It is therefore interesting to investigate the extent to which savings can be made here. In the following-pole rotor I developed, every second magnet was removed and replaced with iron. The remaining magnets were all magnetized in the same direction and the electromagnetic field polarizes the iron in the opposite direction, creating torque.
That sounds good if it saves material. But does the motor have the same performance as the original motor, especially if you only install half as many magnets?
(LH): If you remove half of the magnets, you initially assume that the torque is also half as great. But that was not the case. The follower pole rotor with unchanged geometry was able to achieve around 80 % of the torque of the original rotor. That was an interesting finding. Because from that point on, it was all about optimization. I adapted the shape of the magnets a little more and also increased their height and width. As a result, I was even able to achieve the same torque as the original motor. Of course, a little more than half of the magnet material was used, but it was still possible to reduce the overall torque. However, it has to be said that the motor runs a little less smoothly because variables such as the cogging torque and the torque ripple have changed and the magnetic field is no longer as fluid.
What did you enjoy most or find most impressive about this degree program?
PF: I particularly liked the wide range of topics covered in the program. At the same time, the elective modules gave me the opportunity to delve deeper into my specific interests and thus set my own academic priorities.
I also have very fond memories of the relatively small class sizes in many modules. This created a personal learning atmosphere that facilitated discussion among students and with the instructors and, for me personally, contributed to a very lasting learning experience.
In your master’s thesis, you examined how white-collar crime in companies can be detected and, above all, effectively prevented. 1.) What is the exact title of your master’s thesis, and 2.) how did you approach the project?
PF: 1) The title of my master’s thesis is: “The Integration of Forensic Services into the Three Lines Model.”
2) In addition to conducting a comprehensive literature review, I opted for a qualitative research approach. The starting point for my thesis was an academic examination of the Three Lines (of Defense) model, which is a central component of risk management in many companies and formed the basis of my work. In addition, I analyzed the roles of management, the audit function, and external forensic services in relation to the prevention, detection, and handling of white-collar crime.
Based on the literature and my own conceptual considerations, I subsequently further developed the existing model. In doing so, forensic services were integrated into the Three Lines on the corporate side as well as into the audit as an imaginary fourth line. Another key component was the development of a proprietary index that can serve as an evaluation framework to assess when and to what extent the integration of forensic units might be appropriate.
To ensure practical relevance, I subsequently evaluated the developed concept using qualitative expert interviews. To this end, I conducted interviews with experts from the fields of financial auditing and forensic services, as well as with a representative from the corporate side.
When selecting interviewees, I was able to draw in part on my existing professional network, which I had built up through my work in the fields of forensic investigations and auditing. I specifically reached out to other experts through publications and public profiles. It was important to me to represent as broad a spectrum as possible and to include individuals from audit and consulting firms of various sizes. On the corporate side, I limited myself exclusively to DAX 40 companies.
The insights gained from these interviews ultimately formed the basis for further adapting, refining, and finally critically evaluating the developed model.
What were some of the “aha” moments during your work?
PF: An important starting point for my work was the insight from the literature that the number of unreported cases of white-collar crime remains very high. Although the responsibility for preventing fraud in Germany lies with a company’s legal representatives, studies also show that the public has high expectations of auditors when it comes to uncovering such incidents. In practice, however, relatively few cases are actually identified during the audit. This discrepancy is referred to as the “expectation gap.”
A key “aha” moment in my work was the realization that greater integration of forensic services would not automatically lead to a reduction in this expectation gap. Under certain conditions, it could even widen—for example, if the public is aware of the involvement of forensic units, yet cases that have come to light are not uncovered by them.
Furthermore, it became clear that effectively addressing white-collar crime does not depend solely on companies or auditors. Especially in the area of prevention, impetus from regulators is also necessary. Adjustments and further developments to existing regulations should therefore be made as proactively as possible and not merely in response to scandals.
What specific measures were you able to develop to systematically integrate forensic investigators at the corporate level and in financial audits, thereby sustainably improving fraud prevention and detection?
PF: At the corporate level, a key focus is on making better use of and strengthening internal control mechanisms. One approach is to integrate forensic units into whistleblower systems. These units can act as neutral third parties and, for example, enter test reports into the system. This allows for practical verification of whether incoming reports are processed correctly, deadlines are met, and the anonymity of whistleblowers is actually guaranteed.
Furthermore, the initial receipt of reports can be handled entirely by an independent external third party. This reduces internal conflicts of interest while simultaneously lowering the barrier to reporting. In addition, traditional compliance training can be supplemented with interactive, case-based workshops and targeted cultural initiatives. In particular, working with realistic fraud cases helps raise awareness of typical warning signs (so-called “red flags”). In particularly sensitive situations—such as suspected cases involving top management or complex, high-risk cases—it is also advisable to conduct independent special investigations through external forensic services to ensure an objective review.
The model also provides several starting points for the financial statement audit. A key element is the “Forensic Integration Index” I developed, an indicator for objectively assessing a client’s fraud-related risk profile. If this index exceeds a defined threshold, it can serve as a signal to integrate forensic services into the audit team in a more structured manner.
Ideally, such integration should begin as early as the audit planning phase with joint background research and a forensically oriented “fraud brainstorming” discussion, which can be combined with interactive case study workshops. This allows the audit to be structured in a more targeted and risk-oriented manner from the outset.
In the area of data analysis, particularly in journal entry testing (the software-assisted analysis of large volumes of journal entries), forensic units can define audit parameters to more efficiently identify unusual transactions, such as suspicious reversals. In addition, digital system analyses can facilitate a detailed comparison of actual versus target business processes, allowing anomalies to be examined not only on a sample basis but also in a process-oriented manner. If specific grounds for suspicion emerge during the audit, it would also be possible for forensic units to conduct targeted interviews and verify the authenticity of documents.
Overall, the proposed measures aim to integrate forensic expertise into existing audit and control processes at an earlier stage and in a more structured manner, in order to strengthen both the prevention and detection of white-collar crime.
Are you currently working in the field of white-collar crime, for example, for the police?
PF: I currently work in the Group Compliance department at a measurement services provider. In this role, I deal with fraud prevention in addition to issues such as corruption and bribery, antitrust and competition law, and the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing.
My responsibilities include both preventive and detective/reactive measures. Preventive activities include, for example, further developing the compliance management system as well as designing and conducting workshops. In the investigative and reactive areas, I also assist in clarifying suspicious cases and conducting internal investigations. Even though I do not work in a government setting, I deal with issues that are closely related to white-collar crime. In this respect, my current work also ties in with the topics of my master’s thesis.
What advice would you give to young people interested in International Management?
PF: I would advise young people to get a sense early on of which topics particularly appeal to them. The program covers a very broad range of subjects, which is a strength on the one hand, but can also be challenging, especially at the beginning of the program, if you don’t yet know which direction you want to pursue. That’s why, in my opinion, it’s worth keeping an eye on specialization options early on and choosing courses throughout your studies that align with your own interests. This way, you can make the most of the program’s broad scope for your personal development. Still, you shouldn’t put too much pressure on yourself. Much of this will also become clear over time through projects and practical experience.
Thank you very much!